My Blog List

Showing posts with label Competitive Strength. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Competitive Strength. Show all posts

Monday, 28 February 2011

Merrill Lynch - Wrong Thinking Wrong Conclusions

Last week, Merrill Lynch admitted it had been wrong to hold an “underperform” rating on ARM the Cambridge based technology company since November 2009. Over that period the value of ARM’s shares tripled and they have broken into the FTSE 100!

In a note published last week (entitled “ARM Wrestling”) Merrill admit that they “… had underestimated the potential for royalty rates to increase … and the sheer pace of end market growth addressable by ARM’s customers … and failed to appreciate the impact of Microsoft selecting ARM’s designs as the basis for the next generation if its Windows software …”.

How did they get it so wrong and for so long? This is the inevitable outcome of using conventional financial and business analysis to attempt to pick the next winner in an increasingly unconventional world. This way of thinking also assumes that all businesses perform in a conventional way and will therefore perform broadly in line with market conditions rather than outperform or underperform.

However ARM is not a conventional business in the way it thinks and behaves. If we apply the Competitive Strength perspective we can see that ARM have achieved a Competitive Strength condition of Excellent and may even have progressed to Free. Quite simply this means they are able to do things that other businesses with weaker conditions of competitive strength cannot. In this case the outcomes are higher royalty levels, customers who have exceptional rates of end market growth, major breakthrough deals with the likes of Microsoft and so on.

Merrill’s conventional approach is trying to spot the golden eggs, which goose is likely to lay them, as well as where and when. The Competitive Strength perspective identifies which geese have the capability to lay golden eggs because, as the Competitive Strength research base shows, that is invariably what they do. Can you also spot which is likely to to be the short term and which the long term investment perspective?

In spite of Merrill’s wrong call the market as a whole appears to recognise what ARM were capable of, though how many of the investment decision makers involved really know why is still a question in our view.

Can ARM do now wrong? Well watch out for any conventional sounding statements from the company, any sense of complacency and that they feel they have cracked it (no pun on the egg theme intended) and have become unassailable. This can be a sign that the Competitive Strength condition, how they think and behave, is slipping towards the Comfortable condition, where they will become vulnerable to external forces.

What about Merrill? They have now upgraded their stance on ARM to “neutral”. This indicates they are still using conventional thinking and analysis and/or maybe “neutral” is about exciting as it gets at Merrill Lynch these days.

Exceeding Expectations is brought to you by Steve Goodman and Tony Ericson partners in Achievement Coaching International where we help businesses to learn different thinking to enable different actions that deliver the different results that Make a Big Difference.. It is one of our "Excellence Quartet" of blogs promoting the cause of Excellence as the key to prosperity. We publish regular articles using a recent business/financial topic to highlight different perspectives and conclusions to those obtained by conventional thinking and techniques. You can read the other three blogs at "Business Bloop Award", "You're having a laugh ... seriously?" and "Capitalism or ... Common Sense".

Friday, 22 October 2010

The analyst who gets it

We have previously criticised conventional financial analysts' pronouncements on the fortunes and futures of businesses. Too often we believe their assessments and opinions do not identify the key drivers of performance because they are too focussed on the financial factors.

However Richard Fletcher, city editor of the Daily Telegraph has spotted perhaps the first example of an analyst who in his words "gets it". Richard Fletcher himself must have been "getting it" for sometime himself because he clearly knows one when he sees one.

The analyst is Marc Geall and his 26 page note on Autonomy, a software business is the subject of Richard Fletcher's article in the Daily Telegraph on 13th October. He reports that Mike Lynch, the Chief Executive of Autonomy, "used to claim that the city analysts didn't get it. With limited experience of software companies, he argued, the city scribblers struggled to get a grip on the complex £3.4bn business he had spent years building".

However Richard Fletcher reveals that Geall actually worked for Autonomy for more than two years before joining Deutche Bank in June, so he knows the company from the inside. Richard Fletcher states that whilst "Geall does stress at the beginning of his note that Autonomy hs a "unique product" that "dominates", his dissection of the group's management and business model is damning".

Here are some of the extracts he quotes from Geall's note:

"The management structure, control and sytems at Autonomy are more representative of a start-up than a major global player ... The senior management team is talented but lacks bandwidth. This can lead to some decision paralysis as the middle management is sometimes limited in its autonomy".
Autonomy still manages a very flat structure with a tight chain of command into the CEO and CFO,"... Although they have managed this effectively to date, we believe the business is becoming too big and time is now becoming the limiting factor. There after all only 24 hours in the day and 90 days in the quarter."
But it is not only the senior management that is found wanting. Autonomy's sales force are "hunters not farmers", according to to Geall and ill-prepared for the inevitable transition to account management as Autonomy grows and the number of "repeat" customers increases."
"Autonomy's margin structure is too high ... and the investment in the business has lagged revenues ... [which] could affect customer satisfaction towards the product and value it delivers."
Autonomy's service business is "too lean" ... "risks falling short of standards demanded by customers".

We are not saying that Geall is necessarily right, we don't have the facts behind these statements to make that judgement. What struck us though is that for the first time in our experience here was an analyst focussing on HOW a business thinks and behaves and the potential consequences this has for future performance, rather than just WHAT it does financially. Compare this with a few other analysts' comments reported in the Telegraph on the same day.

"Traders said that the efficiency review had hit ... and that there were worries over the prospect of the government attempting to renegotiate contracts".
"... he expected first half cash flow to be miserly ... and advised investors to bring your magnifying glass. He added that he anticipated continued revenue declines".
"... one of the most compelling retail roll-out opportunities ... clear and visible growth over the medium term backed by strong cash generation".
"... remains structurally challenged given its geographical and revenue channel exposure ..."

We do not claim that any of these are wrong, just very one dimensional. They are commenting only on financial outcomes, WHAT has happened and WHAT may happen rather than on HOW these outcomes came about. By contrast Geall comments on aspects of the core characteristics of Autonomy's organisational culture, how it thinks and behaves and how these could impact on future performance.

There is a growing realisation, backed by a growing body of research that the deep seated managerial and behavioural values and competences of a business are the main determinant of whether, over time, it will substantially outperform its competitors and successfully withstand unpleasant surprises. These values and behaviours manifest themselves in the form of the Competitive Strength condition of a business, which is:

How capable a business is compared to those that want to beat it
and
How capable a business is of mitigating those forces out there that can cause it to be beaten.

So without knowing it, we suspect, Geall has offered his analysis of the weaknesses in Autonomy's Competitive Strength condition and what the consequences could be. These weaknesses may currently be hidden by the advantage of its products' uniqueness and market dominance. If Geall is right then the research on which the concept of Competitive Strength is based demonstrates they could be doing up to twice as well right now. Furthermore unless corrective action is taken the cracks will start to show, it is only a question of when.

Should Autonomy take Geall's comments on board, given that he cannot be accused of not knowing the business? Autonomy shares fell substantially after it warned two weeks ago that full- year profits would be below market expectations, blaming "volatility rather than demand" in its markets. So if we were them and knew what we know then we would take Geall's analysis seriously. But we are not them and they may or may not know what we know, so we shall see.

Finally thanks to Richard Fletcher for spotting and publishing the difference. Let's hope it encourages more analysts to think about HOW rather than WHAT.

Exceeding Expectations is brought to you by Steve Goodman and Tony Ericson of Business Breakthrough Coaching. It is one of our "Excellence Quartet" of blogs promoting the cause of Excellence as the key to prosperity. We publish regular articles using a recent business/financial topic to highlight different perspectives and conclusions to those obtained by conventional thinking and techniques. You can read the other three blogs at "Business Bloop Award", "You're having a laugh ... seriously?" and "Capitalism or ... Common Sense".

Monday, 16 March 2009

The Fallacy of Market Share

In our last Exceeding Expectations article we demonstrated how being in a high growth market sector and/or having a temporary market advantage are not reliable indicators of long term performance for a business. In this article we explain why “market share” is misunderstood and misused as an indicator of future performance – and so often also as a strategic goal. Given that the ONLY rationale offered to persuade Lloyds TSB shareholders to support the merger with HBOS was the “largest-market-share-in-UK-retail-banking-Gordon-has-given-us-the-nod” argument , this is a highly relevant subject to address.

The argument in favour of achieving high market share is that this creates many advantages that lead to superior financial performance. This fallacy has a corollary– the conclusion that high market share requires a very large organisation. Frequently this prompts boards to “shortcut” their way to increased market share through merger and acquisition. However as the record shows, M&A has a chance of between 50 and 80% of failing to produce value; what does this say about the advantages of high market share?

The research on this subject appears superficially to back the notion that high market share leads to superior financial performance. However one piece of research identified a crucial element needed if this superior performance is to be sustainable. The research, carried out at Harvard and still ongoing is titled Profit Impact of Market Strategies (PIMS). This research involved gathering performance data over many years from many thousands of business units to identify the business strategies most likely to lead to success in a range of contexts. In their book (“The PIMs Principles”) Robert Buzzell and Bradley Gale showed how their PIMS research discovered that only market share growth based on relative perceived superior quality will result in market share growth that delivers sustainable superior financial performance.

For an example of how the lack of relative perceived superior quality results in poor financial performance in spite of high market share we need look no further than DSG, the owners of Currys and PC World. This company built itself into the market leading electricals retailer and showed all the characteristics of a high market share operator, e.g. using its buying power to offer low prices and occupying prime retail sites throughout the UK. Three years ago, after one of our clients suffered one of the worst customer experiences we have witnessed from PC World’s so called Business Division, we looked at DSG from our Competitive Strength perspective and warned that all was not well. Since then other commentators began to voice concerns and in due course DSG’s profits began to slide along with its share price.

Then came the recession and of course this has meant a tough period in retail. In spite of this a few retailers have been able to report results that exceeded expectations whereas DSG announced trading results that were every bit as bad as expected. The media’s financial and business pundits once again cited market conditions, the credit crunch, shifts in demand for one technology or another, and so on. DSG attempted to cushion the bad news by reporting that trials of new store formats had delivered increased sales and margins. On the strength of this news one analyst actually changed his recommendation from sell to hold – obviously he has never heard of the Hawthorne Effect (research that showed the refurbishing of working environments can improve performance – but only for an extremely short time). The thinking (or is it a Prayer?) goes that if the market leader upgrades all their stores, the improved performance seen in the trial will replicate across the business to restore the high market share and once again deliver high profits.

We have to ask - has this analyst or any of the other commentators actually tried to buy anything recently from a DSG store? If they had, they might just understand why even an infinite number of expensive store refits will not stop DSG plunging further and crashing – why there is no sign of a competent pilot and no River Hudson nearby.

Recently, my wife and I popped into our local (large) branch of Currys. She wanted to buy a new electric iron. There was a reasonable choice of items lined up along a display shelf. The chief decision maker examined them and finally decided which one she wanted to buy. We looked at the lower shelves for the boxed item. It was not there – in fact, there were boxed examples of fewer than half the items “on sale”. After a search, I found two assistants busy chatting and asked for help. Visibly irritated at being interrupted, one of them came to the shelf, removed the label, disappeared to a computer terminal and then returned. “We don’t have one, but you can order it”. We asked when, if we were to order, would it be available? He did not know. He asked another lady assistant who said that a delivery would be in 4 days. Would it include that item? “Probably – if you order it”.

My wife asked if we could buy the display item? Could we have the box and instructions? “Oh no, we throw those away. We would be full of cardboard boxes, wouldn’t we?” My wife then asked how much reduction they would offer for the item as incomplete. “Oh no, we can’t reduce it because it is a current stock item. You can order it”. She walked out, fuming. We went straight to Sainsburys – a whole 300 yards. Within 10 minutes she found what she wanted and bought it.

This is why DSG are doomed. Disastrous Customer Service experiences and the inability to deliver the basic function of a “shop” (somewhere that sells things you can buy there and then) demonstrates DSG’s relative perceived inferior quality. Disposing of the packaging and thereby devaluing all their display stock is simply one of many inevitable, stupid consequences of the core problem. This core problem is low Comparative Competitive Strength for which no amount of “bigness”, whether in market share or anything else, can compensate.

Their new chief executive is promising change “but it will take time”. With rapidly diminishing Competitive Strength, my friend, you don’t have the time. This is a business behaving in a way that spells disaster even in good times. What hope does it have in a time of economic crisis? The Abyss looms – and a great deal faster than you may wish to believe. Size matters, a bit – the Titanic took much longer to slide under the waves than a rowing boat, but the only variable was the time, not the sinking. And, as a very large organisation, when DSG crashes, the tsunami will drown many others that do not deserve to die. If, as they have announced, DSG think they need redundancies – it is not in the stores – it is in their leadership.

If you own DSG shares, forget them, write them off. If you are a DSG employee, sorry, look for another job now. If you are a DSG Supplier – get ready for massive contractions at any minute. If you are a DSG Creditor – take protective action now. If you are a Financial Analyst, ask yourself if you are saying the right things but for the wrong reasons and consequently at risk now of giving wrong advice? If you are an Institutional Investor (on behalf of my pension fund perhaps?) and if you still hold a stake, you should be sacked, now.

If you think we are just picking on DSG, what about Lloyds TSB and HBOS? Sorry, Lloyds shareholders, it is probably too late, get ready to sue your Board members and the government.

The only hope the UK has in these troubled times is for every business to raise its game NOW. There is no longer time to pussy foot around. Every enterprise that fails, as DSG seems determined to do, will be an avoidable burden on the few survivors. Don’t expect the Government to help – they haven’t a clue about Comparative Competitive Strength or its importance to saving the British economy – just a few stalwart pursuers of Excellence will, if the banks don’t stop them, provide the only solid base for our future economic survival.

Frankly it makes us want to cry. But if you are of stouter heart, and want to know more about how you can raise your game – NOW – please have look at our website here and at the Comparative Strength Report page here.

Exceeding Expectations is brought to you by Steve Goodman and Tony Ericson. It is one of our "Excellence Quartet" of blogs promoting the cause of Excellence as the key to prosperity. Each blog has a new article each month using a recent business/financial topic to highlight different perspectives and conclusions from those obtained using conventional thinking and techniques. You can read the other three blogs are "You're having a laugh ... Seriously?", Business Bloop of the Month Award", "Capitalism or ... Common Sense" .

Thursday, 22 January 2009

The Fallacy of the "Market"

As we move into the early part of 2009 one of the business names shortly to be added to the casualty list is Foxtons estate agents.

Foxtons grew rapidly on the back of the London property boom and became famous for the Minis in Foxtons livery darting around the streets of London. Jon Hunt, the founder, sold the business to BC Partners for £360m just before the credit crunch. Now comes the news that Foxtons have breached their banking covenants and BC Partners have conceded that its decision to buy the business was a mistake. “As housing markets fall, so do estate agents, so we got that wrong. In hindsight, we made the wrong assessment of the market,” said a spokesman.

Well yes you did, but the really wrong assessment was not “of the market” – it was of the company itself. Jon Hunt had done a great marketing job, the company Minis were just one example. He rode the boom astutely, opening more offices, taking on more staff, positioning the business as THE estate agent in London and timing his exit impeccably – good luck to him! Yet many who had attempted to buy or sell a house with Foxtons had perceived the company as inefficient, its staff incompetent and unprofessional (remember the Put-A-Sign-on-Anybody’s scandal?) and putting its own interests before those of its clients. A bit of research amongst Foxtons’ clients and London house owners who had had anything to do with them would have revealed a business that was likely to be unsustainable other than in a booming market.

There is a mindset amongst many investment analysts and managers that leads them to believe that investing in businesses in so called “high growth” market sectors and/or with apparently unassailable market advantage in their products/services is the Holy Grail that will produce the stellar returns they seek. This leads them all too often in to over-valuing the “biggest” – because, “obviously it must have grown more”. The same immature logic has driven company directors to pursue Top Line growth regardless of expense, because it will impress these analysts who will then recommend their shares.

This is just rubbish thinking because all “high growth” sectors and any market advantage are at best temporary and frequently illusory as BC Partners experience with Foxtons illustrates. There is no substitute for being a good, well run business that has developed a high level of Competitive Strength that ensures it stays that way.

In 2003 Irish Drinks Group C&C, launched Magners Cider. Described as “a triumph of marketing” the new concept of “Cider Over Ice” swept all before it. Sales grew strongly during three successive summers and into 2007’s early Spring heat wave. Over the same period C&C’s share price grew strongly too, from €2 to €14. However in reality this was based on just two assumptions – that no competitor would enter the market and that it wouldn’t rain.

Well, S&N launched Bulmers Over Ice in 2006 and recaptured 20% of the market - and it started to rain. In two months C&C shares dropped to €6 as sales and profits collapsed. The business simply did not have the Competitive Strength to maintain and build on the advantage it had gained with its new product. Their share price is now around €1.45, their Chief Exec has gone to be replaced by John Dunsmore former Chief Exec at, guess where, S&N!
For the most spectacular example of a booming market masking fundamental weaknesses in the business, look no further than the banks!

However an example of how this works in reverse is Sainsbury’s. For some time their market share, sales and profits wilted as competition from Tesco, Asda and Morrison’s hotted up. Financial and investment analysts were forever claiming that Sainsbury’s must reposition up market, down market, sideways, anywhere where there was less competition if they were to have a future. Successive managements arrived, tried, failed and went.

Then along came Justin King, with the novel strategy of making Sainsbury’s a “better business”. The result has been growing market share, sales, profits and the resilience that will see it through the downturn, all of which had nothing to do with the market. Can you imagine the previous state of the company enabling it to introduce its expanded non-food offer and its new value lines as effectively as they have done now? As a “better business” Sainsbury’s are not only spotting changes in the needs of their customers but are actually now capable of responding.

We are not saying that the market and/or market advantage from a break through product or process will not have an effect on the performance of a business, it is just that on its own it is not as crucial as many think it is and certainly not as significant as Competitive Strength. Businesses with high Competitive Strength conditions, what we call Excellent or Free, can not only respond faster to market changes but are frequently the instigators of those changes. They can profit from high growth and continuously create and renew their market advantage.

Experience and rock solid research has proven that how an organisation thinks and behaves, the deep seated managerial and behavioural values and competences of a business, are the main differentiator of whether over time they will substantially outperform their competitors and successfully withstand unpleasant surprises.

This manifests itself in the form of Competitive Strength, a new measure of business performance.

Yes, you can actually measure Competitive Strength, either in your own business or in any businesses you are considering investing in. The Competitive Strength Report Process is the only tool available from anyone, anywhere that provides an objective measure of Competitive Strength compared to the very best in the world. The Competitive Strength Report enables a business leadership to understand where they are positioned, in comparison to the very best, where their main threats lie, what the implications are and helps them decide very clearly, collectively and speedily what they need to do. There is nothing else as fast, as accessible or as affordable.

Find out more about it on our Competitive Strength web site page – or at the Competitive Strength Report website.


Exceeding Expectations is brought to you by Steve Goodman & Tony Ericson of ChangeWORLD. For more lighthearted comment with a serious point on current business related topics go to our You’re having a laugh … seriously? and Business Bloop of the Month Award

Wednesday, 27 August 2008

The Olympic "edge"

When you are running a blog entitled "Exceeding Expectations" you really have to include an article on the Beijing Olympics and especially the performance of Team GB.

We define Excellence as exceeding both requirements and expectations, requirements being tangible and expectations being intangible. The team exceeded requirements in terms of both medal count and final position in the medal table. In doing so they exceeded the expectations of their funders and sponsors and of the country as a whole. Certainly we did not expect to become a sporting superpower but that's exactly what fourth in the Olympic medal table makes us and boy do we all feel good about that!

We know that Competitive Strength is strongly linked to Excellence. High levels of Competitive Strength in any context enables people to exceed requirements and expectations. In the case of Olympic athletes this is not just about the talent, dedication, hard work and ambition of the athletes themselves but about the back up teams performing to the same level.

Here is Bradley Wiggins a double gold winner and member of the all conquering GB cycling team on this subject. "We have an unbelievable team behind us, management and technical. I know with confidence that when I step onto the track my bike will be in absolutely perfect working order. I can't remember the last time a mechanical problem was a factor in any GB races. When I start a race it is big boost mentally to have certain knowledge that nobody lining up against me starts with an edge. In fact it is always us who have the edge".

With this level of Competitive Strength our cyclists were nigh on unstoppable. They are best cyclists in the world with the best back up team. How many of us running businesses or public sector organisations can honestly say that our front line people can line up to do their jobs every day "knowing they have the edge"? What could they achieve if they did know this?

Our last few articles have focused on the different thinking that is needed to achieve Excellence through Competitive Strength. So what about Usain Bolt then? This man is not built for sprinting says the conventional thinking. He is too tall, his stride is too long and slow and really he is much better suited to 400 or 800m. Well Bolt and his coaches have rewritten some of the rules of sprinting by finding a way to adapt his stride pattern in such a way that the supposed weaknesses are turned into competitive advantage. With this Bolt made history and now other coaches will have to rethink what it takes to sprint 100 and 200m. It certainly is not going to be "run a bit faster the way you have always run", because that isn't enough to beat Usain Bolt!

The last two articles have focused on British Airways and how their conventional thinking dictates their strategy and response to challenges. In the last article we contrasted this with the different thinking displayed by Virgin Atlantic with an example of a stunningly high standard of customer service. Well today Virgin announced a leap in profits from £6m to £34.8M for the year. Profits for the first quarter of the current year are £23.5m and business class passengers (the most profitable) are up 22% with overall numbers up 7.6%. So whose employees know that they " have the edge" and does it make a difference? Answers in the comments please.

So congratulations to Team GB and here's to London 2012. To find out more about Competitive Strength and different thinking go to the brand new Changeworld website.

Monday, 4 August 2008

Above & Beyond

In our last article on the theme of different thinking we highlighted British Airways' explanation for their falling passenger numbers (increases in fares and the economic slowdown) and their persistance in pursuing their strategy of merging with other carriers. We demonstrated how BA are trapped in their traditional thinking and their strategy and responses are therefore all about how they can keep on doing things the way they have always done them.

This article is a story from the same industry which demonstrates different thinking in action.

Two friends of mine had booked a holiday in Barbados. They arrived at the airport looking forward to two weeks on an island paradise. Unfortunately the flight had left the day before and there was not another flight for 4 days! Our friends had got the wrong date in their heads so it was entirely their fault.

They were flying with Virgin so they were taken to the Virgin desk to see if anything could be done. The Virgin staff worked out a way to get them to their destination that day by flying them to Antigua then on an internal flight to Barbados. With transfer charges and the additional flight this was going to cost a further £500 plus. However when Virgin realised our friends were previous customers they immediately waived all the transfer charges.

What is more when our friends arrived in Barbados they took a taxi to their hotel as the coach transfer was obviously not going to be there for them. The next day when they met their Virgin representative at their hotel she asked how they had travelled from the airport to the hotel. When they said by taxi the representative said "just let me have the receipt and we will reimburse you for that".

To say our friends were impressed is an understatement and they never stop telling people how good Virgin were. They were staring a ruined holiday in the face and would have paid almost any sum to have it sorted out. Virgin not only rescued it but did not take advantage of our friends' mistake and only charged the minimum for solving the problem. This is different thinking. None of the "well we will see if we can get you on a flight later in the week" or "well if you write to Head Office they might be able to do something about the charges". All the decisions and actions were taken by front line staff, no reference to managers for permissions was needed.

Different thinking is the key. No amount of carefully written policies and procedures handed down from above would have enabled the Virgin staff to have acted the way they did. The personal and organisational recognition of the value of the existing customer is a manifestation of this different thinking. They not only represent future repeat business but can also be the strongest and lowest cost advocates for your brand.

Also Virgin clearly understand the business they are in and it is not simply transporting people from point A to point B. They know they are in the holiday business and that their customers value their holidays highly. So meeting or even exceeding their customers expectations is the key to success. In the case of our friends it was "you have given us your business, not just on this occasion but previously so we will see that you get your holiday".

This is just one story from one source and no doubt Virgin do not get it right every time. However would you honestly expect to hear even one story like this involving BA, even though they give themselves plenty of opportunities and don't have to wait for a customer to slip up?

This demonstrates the superior level of Competitive Strength that Virgin's different thinking has enabled them to achieve. When Richard Branson set up Virgin Atlantic in direct competition to much larger and often heavily subsidised national flag carriers few industry insiders gave him any chance of surviving. However his airline and the accompanying holiday business has both survived and prospered. As the sector faces up to the massive hike in its fuel bill and slowing demand which business do you think will emerge the strongest? BA with its strategy of getting bigger so it can be what it always has been or Virgin with its highly developed customer service ethos and consequent superior Competitive Strength.

Any business can do what Virgin does and profit from it. To find how and perhaps more importantly why, go to the Competitive Strength website.

Tuesday, 20 May 2008

The “Nice Decade” – was anybody listening?

Last week saw the media pick up on the statement from Mervyn King the Governor of the bank of England that the “Nice Decade” was over and something altogether nastier is now upon us. Significant column inches were devoted to comment and analysis of the Governor’s remarks, including multiple attempts to come up with four words starting with letters that spelt out the word for the economic brown stuff we are now in.

However amongst all the words that were written and broadcast on this subject I can find no mention of the fact that Mervyn King first warned us about the “Nice Decade” coming to an end in October 2003! He said the same in a speech in Leicester four and half years ago as he said last week, but this time with the benefit of hindsight, on risk, asset prices, oil prices etc. He was also too polite to say “told you so”.

In spite of the fact that this man is paid to give us these warnings and that he did so in plenty of time, clearly nobody listened first time round. Government didn’t, banks didn’t, the FSA certainly didn’t, consumers didn’t and many business leaders didn’t. This is in spite of the fact that history shows us that a “Nice Decade” is an aberration, a highly unusual and temporary occurrence and therefore could not possibly last. The current level of economic and business challenge is actually closer to normal conditions; it’s just the nature and causes of the challenge that differ.

Why didn’t they listen? Can it be just explained away as a natural human trait that does not want to hear bad news and in the good times finds it easy to forget the hard times? Or is it the combination of short termism and herd instinct in financial markets? Whilst these have an influence we believe that the root cause is conventional thinking in finance, business, economics and in government. If the thinking does not change, then decisions and action will not change and results will be no more than what you deserve.

Applying our Competitive Strength perspective we can see that those few organisations who have achieved the Competitive Strength condition we call “Free” think very differently to the rest. This is why Warren Buffett enters the downturn with billions of dollars available to make acquisitions whilst the UK government’s coffers are empty. One aspect of this different thinking is that “Free” organisations always expect the unexpected and continuously improve their organisational competence and agility. This “Changeability” is at such a high level that they can respond to both positive and adverse circumstances as they happen, taking maximum advantage of both.

The Competitive Strength point of view shows that the deep seated managerial and behavioural values and competences of a business are the main differentiator of whether over time they will substantially outperform their competitors and successfully withstand unpleasant surprises. Yet this is not conventional thinking. This is not how analysts study performance and share values to make their recommendations, this is not how companies and their advisors evaluate the potential of a merger or acquisition and it is certainly not how government makes and attempts to implement economic policy.

This is just not good enough, as we are now finding out. Applying yesterday’s thinking to the challenges of today and tomorrow is not going to work, whether this is about dealing with the effects of the credit crunch, entering new markets, finding and keeping the skills you need or any of the many challenges we all face. For more insights into why Competitive Strength is such a key factor for business, the economy and even for our ability to tackle global challenges such as climate change please look at the Competitive Strength Report website– and the ChangeWORLD website